HomeAbout UsResourcesShe Might QuizCommunityCoachingDonateMom's Playdate: March 6

Beyond the "What ifs": Life After a Pregnancy Decision

By Cheyenne Erickson

Updated 12/18/2025


It was a five-week swirl. “I don’t want to be pregnant. I don’t want to deal with this.” Paige couldn’t stop thinking about the choice she had to make. One day she would embrace the hardship of being a single mom. The next she scheduled an abortion appointment. And the back and forth continued.

One thing was certain to her: She could never go back to a time when she had never been pregnant. No matter what Paige did, there would be something to work through.

In an interview, Paige Bautz shared her journey of making a pregnancy decision. The sentiment that kept surfacing was, “Either choice is hard, you have to choose your version of hard.”

Let’s unpack what it means to move beyond a pregnancy decision and leave the “What ifs” in the past.

There isn’t a choice that makes it go away

Paige described her dilemma when considering her unexpected pregnancy options:

“Honestly, I have days when I really struggle and I wish I wasn't a parent. Or I get mad at the person who got me pregnant. But if I had gone through the termination, I would have probably had days when I would have thought, ‘I regret my abortion. She would be this many years old now. And she would be doing this.’ So I feel like either way, it's hard. Whatever decision you choose is hard.”

Life will be different than you imagined

Paige explained that women often think life is going smoothly until they get pregnant. She had just been hired for her dream teaching position and was ready to make a life for herself in the city when she discovered her pregnancy. She had to give up her job, move back in with her parents, and take on a caregiving role for her child who had more needs.

She said, “You can think life is going to look one way and it doesn't. And your kid is not the reason for all of your problems. We want to look for somebody or something to blame. Your pregnancy can be a piece of it, but it's definitely not the whole picture.”

For example, she discussed feeling down sometimes because she is a single mom. It could be tempting to think, “If I had just not gotten pregnant then maybe I could be in a long-term relationship.”

However, she has a broader view of life than that.

“The future will not look like how you imagined it,” she explained. “Your life is going to look different, regardless of if you continue with your pregnancy or not. You can move forward, but the way that you look at things in life is going to be different.”

Life After Your Decision

Paige made a choice – not knowing that her daughter would be born prematurely and then diagnosed with cerebral palsy and autism. Her decision involved so much more than she could have imagined.

Paige now has a three-year-old daughter. She takes her daughter to multiple doctor appointments each month and works full-time to support her family.

Paige said, “I always go back and say, okay, this is the choice I made and I have to live with this choice. You don't have to love your choice every day, regardless if you continue or not. But you just have to respect that you did what you thought was best for you.”

Embracing this Season of Life

Life for Paige is nothing like what she’d hoped or dreamed, but it’s still a good life.

“I remind myself, it's going to get easier. Everything is temporary. There's a reason for this, right? Looking back, I can see there was a reason why I got that job in the city. I connected with this wonderful woman who helped me through that really, really hard first few weeks of finding out I was pregnant. There's a reason why I moved back home—so my daughter could be connected to my parents. It might not make sense now, but it will.”

The community for women facing the unexpected. © 2020-2026 She Might™, all rights reserved. Registered 501(c)3. EIN #88-3326052.